PHIL 309: Twentieth Century Analytic Philosophy
LARKIN: Spring 2003
___________________________________________
School |
Representative
Figures |
Critique of
Traditional Philosophy |
True Function of
Philosophy |
Analytic Method |
Common Sense Realism |
Moore Russell |
Too
detached from common sense |
Make
explicit and get deeper understanding of what we know |
Analyze
the sense of Common Sense Propositions |
Logical Atomism |
Russell Wittgenstein |
Misled
by surface grammatical structure of
ordinary language |
Reveal
the underlying structure of reality |
Use
new logic to get at deep logical structure of sentences |
Logical Positivism |
Ayer Carnap |
Traditional
philosophical claims are literally nonsense |
Sort
statements into the empirically meaningful, the tautological, and the
nonsensical |
Apply
the verification principle to statements, test for tautologies |
Ordinary Language Philosophy |
Wittgenstein Austin |
Traditional
philosophical problems are mere pseudo-problems that result from misuse of
language |
Dissolve
philosophical problems by bringing words back to their ordinary use |
Elaborate
the use of ordinary language expressions and their role in various ‘forms of
life’ |
Logico-Linguistic Metaphysics |
Quine Davidson Sellars |
Metaphysically
Extravagant Theorizing |
Weigh
common sense manifest image of world against scientific image |
Make
the commitments of folk theories and language explicit and prime them for
comparison to scientific theories |
Common Claims:
1. Traditional Philosophy is too detached from common sense and ordinary language:
2. Traditional Philosophy is overly speculative and unscientific:
3. Traditional philosophy misuses language in some way:
4. We can use new methods to solve traditional philosophical problems:
5. Traditional philosophical problems must be rejected/dissolved: