The Mental
A mental state is a state which only a creature with a mind can
be in. Propositional attitudes like beliefs and desires, pains,
itches, and other bodily sensations, and perceptual experiences
are examples of mental states.
A propositional attitude is an attitude one bears to a proposition
(which is the sort of thing that can be true or false, and therefore can
be believed or denied). For example believing the proposition to
be true, or disbelieving the proposition, or hoping that it won't come
true, or desiring that it be true, is a propositional attitude. So,
"I fear that Joe might be sick" expresses a propositional attitude (fear)
towards a proposition ("Joe might be sick")
Propositional attitudes are intentional or representational
states.
NOTE: The word "intentional" here is a term of art, and doesn't
especially refer to intentions or decisions, although, like beliefs and
desires, intentions are also a kind of intentional state.
Intentional states have certain distinctive features:
-
Intentional states can be about things being one way rather than another.
For instance, the belief that SIUE is in Edwardsville is about SIUE and
its being in Edwardsville rather than elsewhere; my hope that I'll win
the lottery is about me and my winning the lottery rather than not wining;
my inteniton to go to Chicago is about me and going to Chicago rather than
staying home or going to New York, etc..
-
Intentional states can represent things about an object, without there
being any particular object they are about. For instance, I may
desire to have a glass of water, without there being any particular
glass of water such that my desire is for that glass of water.
-
Intentional states can represent things about an object that doesn't exist
or even may not possibly exist. Ponce de Leon believed that the Fountain
of Youth was in Florida, although there isn't such thing.
-
The mere fact that an intentional state represents some object, and fails
to represent it as being F, does not entail that the state represents the
object as being not-F. There is a gap between "not-(representing it as
F)" and "representing it as (not-F)." For instance, my memories of Fido
do not represent it as having blue eyes. But they do not represent it as
having non-blue (say, brown) eyes either. I just cannot remember what color
its eyes were.
-
Intentional states can represent that a thing X is thus and so, and fail
to represent that a thing Y is that way, even if X is Y. For example,
Don Montero believes that Zorro is a daring and courageous man; he laso
believes that Diego de la Vega is a timid man of little courage.
And yet, Zorro and Diego de la Vega are the same man.
There have been various attempts at finding a single feature or
set of features that all and only mental states and processes have.
Here are some proposals and their problems:
-
Mental states are intentional or representational.
Problem: Propositional attitudes and sensations are indeed intentional.
But there are mental states (e.g., pain) not reducible to these.
But what do our pains represent? And isn't it possible to be anxious and
depressed without being anxious and depressed about anything?
-
We have priviledged access to our mental states. Your knowledge
of your own mental states is not usually based on any evidence or
observation. You can just tell that you're thinking about New York.
While other people do have to infer what you're thinking, from your behavior
and from what you say, you don't have to. being one way rather than another.
You have a kind of special or privileged access to your mental states which
other people lack. By contrast, you don't have any such privileged
access to the rest of the world, including your own body. So we might
take privileged access to be a mark of the mental.
Problem: It's is not clear whether we really do have privileged
access to all of our mental states. For instance, other people might
be in a better position than you are to know whether you're jealous of
your friend's success, or what your unconscious motivations are.
-
Mental states are conscious. There is some peculiar way it
feels to be in those mental states, e.g., pleasure. However, there is no
special way it feels to be 6 feet tall, on the other hand: the statue is
6 feet tall, but it doesn't feel anything. So we might take consciousness
to be a mark of the mental.
Problem: We also seem to have many mental states which aren't
conscious.